My New Dentist Said My Crown Was Trash-Ready, So We Replaced It

Posted on by .

Two weeks ago, my dentist replaced a crown that I got in 2014 when I lived in GA. My dentist said that the crown was trash, and it’s remarkable that it lasted that long. I called the dental practice in GA to explain my dentist’s findings and request a partial refund. They declined, saying I’ve had the crown for 12 years without complaint from me and that it’s too old to warrant any compensation. Is their response fair or legal? Thanks. Tammie from WI

Tammie,

A crown that lasts 11 years has already exceeded the minimum expectations set by most dental standards. While no restoration lasts forever, more than a decade of function suggests the crown served you reasonably well.

Dental crowns

Dental crowns should fit and function confortabley

However, dentists should communicate respectfully when discussing existing restorations. While patients deserve honesty, dentists also aim to avoid unnecessarily harsh characterizations of another provider’s work.

It helps to understand how to interpret strong language.

  • Poorly made crowns typically fail within a few years.
  • Early failure often shows up as pain, loosening, or recurrent decay.
  • A crown that remains stable for 11 years may have been serviceable, even if it now needs replacement.

This doesn’t mean your current dentist is wrong—only that the full picture deserves careful consideration.

What Determines How Long a Dental Crown Lasts?

Insurance guidelines expect crowns to last at least five years, and many last significantly longer. If a crown fails before that window, a dentist may reasonably share responsibility for replacement.

Beyond that timeframe, longevity depends on multiple factors. Daily habits play a major role. Even well-made crowns can fail prematurely in patients who snack frequently or struggle with oral hygiene. For that reason, dentists rarely offer warranties on dental work.

Dr. Steven Brooksher, a Baton Rouge accredited cosmetic dentist, sponsors this post. Read why so many patients view Dr. Brooksher as one of the best dentists in Baton Rouge.

 

A well-known dentist messed up her smile

Posted on by .

In 2014, I received a crown for my right center front tooth. My dentist got the color and the size of the crown wrong. A friend told me about a well-known dentist who replaced my crown in June 2019, but the crown looked gray. He did a second crown, and the color was better, but the tooth was noticeably too long. The second dentist told me that I needed Invisalign, which he provided. My treatment is complete. Now I have a gap between my front teeth. But I also have anxiety now, which has never been an issue. In August, I scheduled an appointment for a third opinion and planned to get an exam, but I was so anxious that the dentist told me to reschedule the appointment when I have time for sedation.

Last month I had two consultations with two more dentists. When I mentioned the second dentist’s name, who left the gap between my teeth, they were skeptical about my report of what happened. I am beginning to think that I need to leave town to find another dentist to correct my smile. Am I too picky? Thanks. Daina from MS

Daina,

We’re sorry that you’ve had two negative experiences and that they led to dental anxiety. Although your second dentist is well-known, it doesn’t mean that he’s a talented, artistic cosmetic dentist who produces beautiful results.

Although most dental schools, the American Dental Association, and many reputable dentists have a negative view of cosmetic dentists, there is an art to producing beautiful smiles. Read the Wikipedia article about cosmetic dentistry. It’s written by someone with an academic mindset who has a condescending attitude about cosmetic dentistry.

We’ve seen many stories like yours. A patient doesn’t like the dentist’s work because their teeth are too white and look fake, but the dentist insists everything is fine. The dentist devalues the patient’s opinion of their smile.

But great cosmetic dentists are sensitive to the patient’s smile and self-perception. If a patient has reservations about their smile, the cosmetic dentist considers the case a failure. And the dentist will redo it.

Photo of woman sitting back in a dental chair with her eyes closed; for information on Baton Rouge sedation dentistry during tooth extraction.

Sedation dentists are empathetic toward patients with dental anxiety

A well-known dentist with an excellent reputation might have great mechanical techniques but be unfit for appearance-related dentistry. Real cosmetic dentists often aren’t the most valued and prominent dentists in the community.

You’re not too picky. Your smile affects your confidence. So, find a cosmetic dentist who respects that. Look for a dentist who is a member of and has credentials from the American Academy of Cosmetic Dentistry. You’ll find a dentist who is an artist, who will accommodate your dental anxiety with sedation options, and who will regain your trust. And a true cosmetic dentist will give you your ideal smile.

Steven Brooksher, DDS, an accredited cosmetic dentist in Baton Rouge, LA, sponsors this post.